Poland’s second chance
Personal, Philosophy, Travels April 12th, 2010It was like a bad dream that kept getting worse.
Just to wake up on Saturday and find out that a plane carrying Poland’s president, Lech Kaczynski, had crashed, was bad enough; that there were no survivors was even worse; that the 96 other dead included the country’s top military, financial and political leaders left me shocked with grief.
And that it happened just as they were flying to Western Russia to mark the 1940 murder of 20,000 of Poland’s elite in Katyn forest outside Smolensk - an act of genocide that wiped out the country’s elite 70 years earlier - turned the shock into paralysis.
I had just returned from Poland, where I was visiting my family for Easter. And I had just witnessed the excitement in Poland about the fact that Russian Prime minister would become the first Russian leader to stand in ceremony commemorating the Katyn massacre and that the shadow of this horrible crime would finally disappear.
Then, as former Polish president Lech Walesa put it, the forests of Katy? claimed their second victims.
To put it into perspective: it’s as if - God forbid - a plane carrying President Obama, Michelle Obama, former President Bill Clinton, Federal Reserve Chair Ben Bernanke, several top senators, chairman of the joint chiefs of staff Admiral Michael Mullen, FBI head Robert Mueller and scores of other government officials went down in flames and killed all on board.
This is how the Gazeta Wyborcza - Poland’s newspaper of record - put it on Saturday when the news broke (translation mine):
Saturday, 8:57 Polish time - President Lech Kaczynski and wife Maria Kaczynska and the entire Polish delegation die in catastrophic plane crash in Smolensk. Responsibility for the leadership of the country is handed to speaker of the senate Bronislaw Komorowski. On Sunday at noon two minutes of silence across the whole country. From Monday obliges a week of national mourning. Prime Minister Donald Tusk is flying to Smolensk. Expedited presidential elections to occur in June.
What does this mean for Poland? As I was reading the Wyborcza, I was as clueless and heartbroken as anyone. But I saw something there - a comment by Walesa - that underscored the significance of this moment:
“Musimy miec dla siebie wiecej milosci.”
Roughly translated, it means “we must have more love for each other” - each other meaning Poles toward fellow Poles.
I immediately thought back to a conversation I had with one of my cousins when I was in Poland this week. Unsolicited, he offered some thoughts on how Poles treat each other. The operative word was “wredni” - which roughly equates to “intentionally malicious.”
It’s not that this is the true national character; it is simply what became of Poland as a result of 45 years of communism. It was a form of government-at-gunpoint that sowed fear, distrust and selfishness into the national soul. This at a time when what it needed most - in the wake of the horrors of World War II - was hope, faith and kinship.
In short, what it needed was “pomocni” - helpful and cooperative. What it got was “wredni.”
Nothing epitomizes this as much as the aftermath of the Katyn murders. The Soviets blamed their cowardly crime on the Nazis and forced Poland to acknowledge and live a massive lie (captured brilliantly in Andrzej Wajda’s 2007 namesake film). The result? Poles turning on their countrymen to kill, punish, lie and guilt them into submission.
The power of the lie cannot be overstated. It lives till this day. Eating Easter lunch with my grandma and her 81-year-old friend a week ago, I had to politely end the conversation when he tried to convince me that it wasn’t the Soviets who did it.
But now there is a chance to overcome all this. True to Walesa’s words, if this tragedy is indeed “Katyn Number 2,” the aftermath doesn’t have to be the same. Communism is dead, Poland is free, and the country can finally come together in grief and kinship the way it never could after World War II.
In short, tragic as it is, this is Poland’s second chance. And I know now that Poland will overcome this, persevere, and re-emerge stronger than before.
Rest in peace, President Kaczynski.

